Yearly Finalists
Annual Finalists (vote winner in bold)
2023
- OL Logan Mankins
- HC Bill Parcells
- LB Mike Vrabel
2022
- OL Logan Mankins
- NT Vince Wilfork
- LB Mike Vrabel
2020
- Head Coach Bill Parcells
- DL Richard Seymour
- LB Mike Vrabel
2019
- S Rodney Harrison
- DL Richard Seymour
- LB Mike Vrabel
2018
- LT Matt Light
- DL Richard Seymour
- LB Mike Vrabel
2017
- CB Raymond Clayborn
- DL Richard Seymour
- LB Mike Vrabel
2016
- CB Raymond Clayborn
- RB Kevin Faulk
- LB Mike Vrabel
2015
- CB Raymond Clayborn
- T Leon Gray
- LB Willie McGinest
2014
- CB Raymond Clayborn
- CB Ty Law
- HC Bill Parcells
2013
- LB Tedy Bruschi
- HC Chuck Fairbanks
- T Leon Gray
2012
- WR Troy Brown
- S Fred Marion
- HC Bill Parcells
2011
- DL Houston Antwine
- QB Drew Bledsoe
- HC Bill Parcells
2010
- DL Houston Antwine
- RB Sam Cunningham
- C Jon Morris
2009
- DL Houston Antwine
- C Jon Morris
- RB Jim Nance
2008
- TE Ben Coates
- C Jon Morris
- RB Jim Nance
2007
- RB Ron Burton
- TE Ben Coates
- WR Stanley Morgan
The Senior Committee inductees
- 2011 – Jon Morris
- 2015 – Houston Antwine
- 2019 – Leon Gray